You can appeal and ask the plan to reconsider the denial. A denial notice has to give the specific reasons for the denial. Examples are: not medically necessary, not covered by the plan, or the maximum amount of treatment allowed under the plan was reached. A consumer has 180 days from the day they receive the denial to file an internal appeal. If the plan or insurer keeps its first decision, the consumer may be eligible for another review, called external review, by an independent third-party reviewer.
Start With the Written Denial Reason

Read your denial notice first. You can appeal, which means asking the plan to reconsider the denial.
The notice has to give the specific reasons for the denial. Examples are "not medically necessary," "not covered by the plan," or "reached maximum amount of treatment permitted under the plan." The U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration lists these in its Model Notices for Group Health Plans.
Some denials say the care wasn't medically necessary. Some call it experimental. Others use a similar exclusion or limit. In those cases, the notice must explain the scientific or clinical judgment behind the denial and apply the plan's terms to your medical situation. Or it must say that an explanation comes free if you ask.
The plan and the insurer (the issuer) must describe the internal appeals and external review processes open to you, including how to start an appeal. The federal rule also requires plans to tell you about your right to appeal and how to begin.
Your individual policy, or your job-based plan's "summary plan description," will tell you how to appeal disputes.
How coverage gets checked before a visit is laid out in Understanding Insurance Verification Before a Neuropathy Consultation.
Request Your Claim File, Codes and Records

You can ask for the papers behind the denial. The plan must give you copies of documents, records, and other information relevant to your claim, and it's free if you ask. If the plan got advice from a medical or vocational expert, you can ask who that was too.
If you ask, the plan must give you the diagnosis and treatment codes, and what they mean, for any denied claim. The model notice says you may ask for copies, free of charge. If you think a coding error may have caused the denial, you have the right to get the billing and diagnosis codes too. To see how nerve testing gets billed, read Nerve Conduction Testing and Insurance: What Gets Billed.
A plan and an insurer must let you look at the claim file, and you can give evidence and testimony as part of the internal claims and appeals process. They must also give you, free of charge, any new or added evidence they considered, relied on, or created in connection with your claim. The full rule is in 45 CFR 147.136 Internal claims and appeals and external review processes.
The plan or insurer must not treat a request for diagnosis and treatment information, by itself, as a request for an internal appeal or an external review. So ask for your records, and also file your appeal on time.
Keep proof of what you do:
- You may also want to send your letter by certified mail, return receipt requested. Then you will have a record that the letter was received and by whom.
- Keep copies of all information about the claim and the denial. That includes Explanation of Benefits papers and a copy of your request for an internal appeal.
- Keep notes, with dates, from any talks with the plan or insurer about the denial.
File an Internal Appeal With Your Plan

In an internal appeal, you ask your own plan to look at the denial again. It gives you a place to hand your health plan information it might not have known about. That's a straightforward way for families to clear up misunderstandings.
Here's how it works, based on the Internal Claims and Appeals and the External Review Process guide from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services:
- You have 180 days from the day you receive the denial to file an internal appeal.
- An internal appeal is generally filed in writing. If the situation is urgent, a spoken appeal is acceptable.
- For pre-service claims (prior authorization, meaning approval needed ahead of time), the decision is due within 30 calendar days. For post-service claims, it's due within 60 calendar days.
- In the group market, there are one or two levels of internal appeal. In the individual market, there is one level.
If you're in a job-based plan, you may have to appeal to your plan a second time before you ask for an external review.
You can file the appeal yourself. Or someone you name to act for you, your authorized representative, can file it. A Consumer Assistance Program (CAP) in your state can also file an appeal for you.
The Department of Labor's Filing a Claim for Your Health Benefits booklet shows what the appeal form asks. You briefly describe why you disagree with the decision, and you may attach added information, such as a physician's letter, bills, medical records, or other documents. Keep copies of the form, your denial notice, and all papers and letters about the claim.
The plan and the insurer must make sure all claims and appeals are decided in a way designed to keep the decision makers independent and impartial. That means fair and not taking sides. You may ask the plan or insurer for a written explanation of a violation, and they must give it to you within 10 days.
Employer Group Plans Under Federal Labor Rules
The Department of Labor's health claim rules generally apply if you get health benefits from a private-sector employment plan.
Whatever the reason for the denial, you have at least 180 days to file an appeal. Check your Summary Plan Description or claims procedure to see if your plan gives you a longer time. Put all information related to your claim in your appeal, especially any added information or evidence you want the plan to consider. Get it to the person named in the denial notice before the 180 days end.
The person who reviews your appeal cannot be the same person who made the first decision. The reviewer also cannot be that person's subordinate, someone who works under them. The reviewer must give no consideration to the first decision.
Time limits for care you already got (a post-service claim) work like this:
- The plan must decide the claim within a reasonable time. That can be no longer than 30 days after the plan receives the claim.
- The plan must decide your appeal within a reasonable time. That can be no more than 60 days after it gets your request to review the denied claim.
Normally, you have to finish your plan's claim process before you file a case in court to challenge the denial of a claim.
Which Plans the Federal Appeal Rules Reach
The federal appeal rules apply to non-grandfathered plans. These include health insurance policies that were first sold, or significantly modified in certain ways, after March 23, 2010.
The federal claims and appeals rule generally doesn't apply to coverage offered by insurers and group health plans that are grandfathered health plans. Check your policy or ask your plan which kind you have.
Illinois-Regulated Plans
In Illinois, your denial notice must say how many levels of appeal the plan has. That's no more than two levels for group plans and one level for individual plans. The notice must also say which level of appeal applies to the decision in the notice.
Illinois healthcare plans must accept and review appeals of determinations and complaints about administrative issues. These aren't about healthcare services, procedures, or treatments. Enrollees or healthcare providers can start them.
When You Can Speed Up or Go Straight to External Review

Some cases can't wait. Generally, an urgent situation is one where your health may be in serious danger. It can also be one where, in your doctor's opinion, you may have pain that can't be well controlled while you wait for a decision on your appeal.
People in urgent care situations may start an internal appeal and an external review at the same time. The HHS-Administered Federal External Review Process for Health Insurance Coverage page explains the federal process.
Illinois gives you two ways to ask for a faster (expedited) external review:
- If waiting for a standard external review would seriously put at risk your life or health, or your ability to regain maximum function, you or your authorized representative may file for an expedited external review.
- If a final denial says the care is experimental or investigational, and your health care provider certifies in writing that the care would be significantly less effective if it is not started promptly, you can ask for an expedited external review.
If you have a sudden severe headache, numbness or weakness in an arm or leg, trouble speaking or seeing, or loss of bladder or bowel control, call 911 or your doctor right away.
Request an Independent External Review
If the plan or insurer keeps its first decision, you may be eligible for another review by an independent third-party reviewer. That's called external review. An independent review organization (also called an IRO) is an entity that does independent external reviews of denials of benefits and of final internal denials of benefits, as set out in the federal rule.
Plans that are not grandfathered under the Affordable Care Act must provide for outside review of claim denials by an independent party. Find consumer assistance in your state to see if you qualify for this external appeal protection.
You have at least four months to file an external review request. After that, you have five business days to send in more information. The Illinois Department of Insurance has a Carrier External Review Notices Checklist. The CMS page Appealing Denials gives more background.
The table below lines up each step of external review with its time limit and who it applies to.
| Step | Time limit | Applies to |
|---|---|---|
| File an external review request | At least 4 months | External review requests |
| File after a final denial letter | 4 months from the letter's date | Illinois-regulated plans |
| File a federal external review | Within 4 months after you receive the denial or final internal denial notice | HHS-administered process |
| Insurer sends documents to MAXIMUS | 5 business days | HHS-administered process |
| You add information | 5 business days | The claimant in external review |
| Standard decision | No later than 45 days after the examiner gets the request | HHS-administered process |
| Expedited decision | Within 72 hours after the examiner gets the request | HHS-administered process |
Illinois External Review Through the Department of Insurance
In Illinois, all health denial letters that involve medical necessity, experimental or investigational treatment, pre-existing conditions, or rescissions must tell you about your right to appeal a coverage decision. A rescission is when coverage is canceled after the fact.
The notice must tell you that you have the right to have the insurer's decision reviewed by an independent review organization that is not associated with the insurer. You do that by sending a written request for an external review to the Department of Insurance, Office of Consumer Health Information, 320 W. Washington St., 4th Floor, Springfield, Illinois 62767. The written notice must also include a copy of the Department's Request for External Review form.
Once you've used up all your internal appeals, the final decision notice must say three things clearly. It must say it is the final decision. It must say all internal appeals have been used up. And it must say you have 4 months from the date of the letter to file an external review.
The Illinois rules apply to all health carrier policies, with some exceptions. Those are policies that cover only a specified disease, specified accident or accident-only coverage, credit, dental, disability income, hospital indemnity, or long-term care insurance.
HHS-Administered Federal External Review
A consumer may file a request with MAXIMUS within four months after getting a notice that a benefit was denied, or a final internal denial notice. You can send your request by mail, by fax, by email, or through a secure online portal.
This federally administered process costs nothing for the health insurance plan, for you, or for your authorized representative.
Here is what happens next:
- The insurer must give MAXIMUS all documents related to the denial within five business days.
- For a standard review, the MAXIMUS examiner must send a written notice of the final decision as quickly as possible, and no later than 45 days after the examiner gets the request.
- For a fast (expedited) review, the examiner must give notice of the final decision as quickly as the medical situation requires, and within 72 hours after the examiner gets the request.
The review covers denials that involve medical judgment. That includes, but is not limited to, denials based on the plan's rules about medical necessity, appropriateness, health care setting, level of care, or effectiveness of a covered benefit. Effectiveness means how well it works.
MAXIMUS decisions are final. Once you get a decision, no further review is available under this federal process.
What Happens After the External Review Decision
If the outside review group decides to overturn the plan's decision, the plan will provide coverage or payment for your health care item or service. If the external reviewer says the claim must be paid, your health plan will have to cover it.
These rules work for tests too. If your health plan denies coverage of a test, such as a body scan, you and your doctor can appeal to the plan. If the plan still refuses to cover the test, you can appeal to an external reviewer.
One study found that in states that had external appeals, consumers won their external appeal against the insurance company a little under half of the time (45%). You can read more in Appealing Health Plan Decisions.
Where to Get Help With Billing Questions Along the Way
At Touch of Wellness Chiropractic, you get clear, honest answers about what your insurance covers and what it doesn't, without being given the runaround.
Illinois Legal Aid Online gives two tips for bills:
- If a medical bill does not have enough detail or lists services you do not know, ask the provider for an itemized bill.
- If you have a surprise bill or a balance bill, you can call the federal No Surprises Helpdesk at (800) 985-3059. You can also call the Illinois Department of Insurance Office of Consumer Health Insurance at (877) 527-9431.
For more on what care can cost here, read Neuropathy Care Costs and Coverage in Tazewell County: A Guide. You can also read about our Neuropathy Care. To see how we do our work, read about Chiropractic Care.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a standard external review decision take?
No more than 45 days. Standard external reviews are decided as soon as possible, and the decision comes no later than 45 days after the request was received.
Does my provider's own appeal extend my deadline?
No, not unless your provider is acting as your authorized representative. In Illinois, notices must tell you that your deadlines for an appeal or an external review request are not postponed or delayed by provider appeals. The exception is when the provider is acting as your authorized representative. Keep track of your own deadline.
Do I have to pay to appeal or to request an external review?
Generally, no. Plans generally can't charge any money for filing claims and appeals, and the plan or insurer must pay the cost of the independent organization that does the external review. If a filing fee does apply, it must be waived if paying it would cause an undue financial hardship. The annual limit on filing fees for any one claimant within a single plan year must not exceed $75. Ask your plan about any fee before you pay it.
What if my plan misses its deadline to decide my appeal?
You may be able to start an external review. In Illinois, notices must tell you that you can file one if the insurance carrier has delayed the internal appeal for 30 days for concurrent or prospective reviews, or 60 days for retrospective reviews. Under the federal rule, when a plan or insurer fails to strictly follow the internal appeal requirements, you may start an external review, as it applies to your case. Check your notice to see which time limit fits your claim.
Can I sue if the external review upholds the denial?
You may have that option. If the denial is upheld, there is no further review under the appeals process. But you may have other options under State or Federal law, such as filing a lawsuit.
Is my claim too small to qualify for external review?
No. There is no minimum dollar amount a claim must reach to qualify.
Take the Next Step
Here's the path in three steps. First, get the written reason for the denial. Second, appeal with your records. Third, take it to external review if the plan keeps its decision. You can appeal and ask the plan to reconsider the denial. The internal appeals process gives you a place to give your plan information it might not have known about, which is a straightforward way to clear up misunderstandings. And if the external reviewer says the claim must be paid, your health plan will have to cover it. Before your next exam, check what your plan covers.
Touch of Wellness Chiropractic is a chiropractic practice in Morton, Illinois, caring for adults and families in Morton and the greater Peoria area who have back, neck, joint or nerve pain. Our work includes chiropractic care, Neuropathy Care, Shockwave Therapy, Cold Laser Therapy, Acupuncture, Massage Therapy and DOT Physicals. Would you like to book a visit with our team? Book Appointment